Is Your Building a Higher-Risk Building? 14 Tests Under the Building Safety Act

A property team with a mixed estate asks the same question every few months, usually after a lender, an insurer or a board paper raises it: does the Building Safety Act apply to us.
For most of our clients the answer is no, and the reason fits in a line. A higher-risk building in the occupation regime has to contain at least two residential units. A thirty-storey tower full of law firms and insurers does not, so it is not a higher-risk building for these purposes.
That answer is a relief for most buildings on a commercial estate. The problem is the exceptions, and they are not the ones people expect. A university with halls of residence. A school with boarding accommodation. An office on floors two to six of a tower with flats above it. In each case the building is inside the regime, and the organisation occupying part of it frequently has no idea.
So the useful exercise is not reading the Act. It is applying the tests to each building and writing the answer down. Here are fourteen, drawn from section 65 of the Building Safety Act 2022, the Higher-Risk Buildings Regulations 2023 and the government's criteria guidance.
The core test
1. Two limbs, and both must be met. Section 65 defines a higher-risk building, for the in-occupation part of the regime, as a building in England that is at least 18 metres in height or has at least 7 storeys, and contains at least 2 residential units.
Height or storeys is an either/or. Residential units is a requirement. Miss the second limb and nothing else in the test matters.
2. A commercial-only building is outside it. The direct consequence of limb (b), and the answer most occupiers are looking for. No residential units means no higher-risk building, regardless of height, use, occupancy or storey count.
3. The thresholds are alternatives, and failing both ends the enquiry. A building meeting the 7-storey threshold does not need measuring against the height threshold, and one at 18 metres does not need its storeys counted. Equally, a building that is 17 metres and 6 storeys is not a higher-risk building regardless of whether it meets the use criteria.
4. This definition does not travel to other legislation. Worth making to anyone handed a single "Building Safety Act" answer for the whole estate. The guidance states that the definitions in the Act and Regulations do not amend definitions of building in other legislation, or in other parts of the Act.
5. "Relevant building" is a different test again. Section 117 defines a relevant building for the leaseholder protections in sections 119 to 125 and Schedule 8. A separate definition for a separate purpose, and conflating the two produces the wrong answer in both directions.
Where commercial and campus estates get caught
6. Mixed use is inside the regime. The guidance could not be clearer, and gives its own example: if a building contains a shopping centre but also has two residential units, then it is a higher-risk building, provided it meets the height or storeys threshold.
So an office floor in a tower with apartments above sits inside a higher-risk building. The occupier of that floor is not the accountable person, but it shares a building with a regime it needs to understand, and the co-ordination questions are the same ones we see in fire safety. Our note on the fire safety order articles that matter covers the shared-building machinery.
7. University accommodation and school boarding are inside it. Stated expressly in the guidance: boarding accommodation in schools and university accommodation would be considered higher-risk buildings, provided they meet the height or storeys threshold, because they contain residential units.
For an education client this is the finding. Teaching blocks and libraries are outside the regime on limb (b); halls of residence at or above the threshold are inside it. The estate therefore has two populations of building under two regimes, and the register has to say which is which. Our note on duties education settings miss covers the wider picture.
8. What counts as a residential unit is broad. A residential unit is defined at section 115 as a dwelling or any other unit of living accommodation. The guidance's examples include a flat, a studio flat, a house in multiple occupation, and shared accommodation within university halls, for instance a bedroom with a shared kitchen and bathroom.
That last example is the one to note. A cluster flat where students have a bedroom each and share facilities is residential units, not one unit.
9. Supported and sheltered accommodation counts too. Buildings containing supported and sheltered accommodation are higher-risk if they meet the threshold, and the guidance's examples include domestic abuse refuges, children's homes and sheltered homes for older people that do not fall within the definition of a care home.
10. The exclusions are narrower than they look. Regulation 8 excludes a building that comprises entirely of a care home, a hospital, a secure residential institution, a hotel or military barracks, along with buildings containing Ministry of Defence or forces living accommodation.
Read "comprises entirely of" carefully. A hotel is excluded; a building that is mostly a hotel but also contains two flats is not.
How height and storeys are actually measured
Need Expert H&S Guidance?
Our qualified consultants can help you implement the right health & safety measures for your business.
This is where an assumed answer most often turns out to be wrong, because the prescribed methods are not the ones a surveyor would use by default.
11. Height: ground level to the top of the floor surface of the top storey. Regulation 5 measures height from ground level to the top of the floor surface of the top storey, ignoring any storey which is a roof-top machinery or roof-top plant area, or which consists exclusively of roof-top machinery or plant rooms. Where the top storey is not directly above the lowest part of the adjacent ground, height is measured vertically from that lowest part to a horizontal projection from the top of the top storey's floor surface.
Two consequences. Plant at roof level does not add height. And a building on a slope is measured from the low side, which can push a borderline building over the line rather than under it.
12. Storeys: three things are ignored. Regulation 6 requires you to ignore any storey below ground level, any roof-top machinery or plant area or storey consisting exclusively of roof-top plant rooms, and any storey consisting of a gallery with an internal floor area of less than 50% of the internal floor area of the largest storey vertically above or below it which is not below ground level.
The gallery rule is the one nobody applies. A mezzanine or gallery level under half the footprint of the largest storey does not count towards the seven.
13. Below ground has its own test, and it is strict. Regulation 6(3) treats a storey as below ground level if any part of the finished surface of the ceiling of the storey is below the ground level immediately adjacent to that part of the building.
Any part of the ceiling, not the floor. A lower ground floor that is partly below the adjacent ground on one elevation may be excluded from the count on that basis, which again moves borderline buildings.
14. Being outside the regime is not being outside fire safety law. The last and most important test, and the government guidance makes the point itself: in addition to the higher-risk regime, a building may be subject to other legislation and statutory duties such as the Regulatory Reform (Fire Safety) Order 2005, and you will need to work with the relevant dutyholders in the building.
This is where the conversation should land for most commercial occupiers: usually no for the higher-risk regime, yes for the amendments the Act made to fire safety law, which reach ordinary workplaces. Our note on section 156 duties covers those, and fire strategy versus fire risk assessment covers the two documents that must agree.
The fourteen, as a per-building decision
| Test | Source | Usual answer for a commercial estate |
|---|---|---|
| 18m or 7 storeys, and 2+ residential units | s65 | Fails limb (b) |
| Commercial-only building | s65(1)(b) | Outside the regime |
| Thresholds are alternatives; failing both ends it | Guidance | Checked once, recorded |
| Definition does not travel to other law | Guidance | Often assumed it does |
| "Relevant building" is a separate test | s117 | Frequently confused |
| Mixed use is inside | Guidance | The catch for office floors |
| University and school residences inside | Guidance | The catch for campuses |
| Residential unit, broadly defined | s115 | Cluster flats count individually |
| Supported and sheltered accommodation | Guidance | Relevant to some estates |
| Exclusions only if comprised entirely | reg 8 | Narrower than assumed |
| Height ignores roof-top plant | reg 5 | Changes borderline cases |
| Storeys ignore galleries under 50% | reg 6 | Almost never applied |
| Below ground tested at the ceiling | reg 6(3) | Almost never applied |
| The Fire Safety Order still applies | Guidance | The real answer |
Rows eleven to thirteen matter for any borderline building, and one point is live: following a First-tier Tribunal decision dated 3 July 2024, the department is consulting on amending the Regulations to make clear that roof gardens should not be considered a storey, and says that in the meantime its view remains that they are not. If your seventh storey is a roof garden, document that now rather than assume it.
Holding this as a per-building determination, with the measurement basis, the residential unit count and the date somebody decided, is a practical case for health and safety consultants and software working as one system, because the answer changes with a change of use rather than with time. Periodic health and safety audits should ask one question: which of our buildings contain residential units, and who wrote that down.
How this compares internationally
For groups with property in several countries, the British higher-risk regime is a useful illustration of something we rarely see: a regime defined by the building rather than by the employer or the activity.
Almost every occupational safety duty we work with attaches to an employer, an undertaking or a dutyholder. This one attaches to a structure, measured in metres and storeys, with duties following from the building's characteristics rather than from what anybody does inside it. That makes it easy to map onto an asset register and hard to map onto a group safety standard, which is organised around people and activities.
Several other jurisdictions regulate tall residential buildings through building codes and fire authority approvals rather than a separate occupation-phase regime with its own regulator. So the asset register travels, the regime does not, and who holds the duty for a building is answered locally. Our guide to health and safety legislation covers how these frameworks differ, and our note on statutory building checks covers the recurring obligations alongside.
Where Arinite fits
Arinite does not act as an accountable person and does not prepare safety case reports. What our health and safety consultants do is the step before that: go through the estate building by building, establish which ones contain residential units at all, apply the prescribed height and storey methods near the threshold, and record the determination so it can be produced when a lender or insurer asks. For most commercial clients that ends with a short, defensible note saying the regime does not apply, which is worth having. We support 1,500+ businesses in 50+ countries and protect 100,000+ employees, with 95%+ client retention over 15+ years.
We work extensively with office-based, property and real estate, education, legal and hospitality clients, and education and mixed-use estates are where the answer is least obvious. A fire risk assessment does the work in either case, and where a managing agent holds the building our note on outsourced facilities management covers the duties that stay with you. For campuses facing the protective security question too, our note on Martyn's Law for schools, colleges and universities deals with that regime.
For multi-country groups, our global health and safety consultants keep the asset register consistent while applying each country's own building regime, and our international health and safety consultants can say where a separate occupation-phase regime exists.
Do one thing this week. Take the estate list and mark every building that contains residential units of any kind, including halls, flats above offices and boarding accommodation. Then book a free gap analysis and we will tell you in one call which of them the regime reaches.
Related Articles
Written by
Arinite Health & Safety Consultants
Health & Safety Expert at Arinite


