Skip to content

Arinite is Your One-Stop Shop for Global Health and Safety Compliance For Local Expertise

Accident Investigation: 15 Things the Law and HSG245 Require

A
Arinite Health & Safety Consultants
November 21, 2026
11 min read
Accident Investigation: 15 Things the Law and HSG245 Require

There is no regulation that says you must investigate an accident. Look for one and you will not find it.

What you will find is a duty to monitor and review your preventive measures, a duty to review a risk assessment the moment there is reason to suspect it is no longer valid, a duty to record certain injuries, and a statutory right held by safety representatives to examine the causes of accidents at your workplace whether or not anyone asked them to. Put those together and investigation becomes unavoidable, but it arrives through the back door, which is why it is so unevenly done.

The practical consequence is that the quality of an investigation is judged against your own arrangements rather than against a prescribed procedure. If your arrangements say nothing about how incidents are examined, there is no standard to have met and nothing to show. Fifteen things the law and the HSE's workbook actually require.

Where the duty comes from

1. Regulation 5 is the source, and the operative words are "monitoring and review". Regulation 5(1) of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999 requires every employer to make and give effect to such arrangements as are appropriate, having regard to the nature of the activities and the size of the undertaking, for the effective planning, organisation, control, monitoring and review of the preventive and protective measures.

Monitoring and review is where incident investigation lives. An organisation that cannot describe how it examines what went wrong has not made arrangements for reviewing its preventive measures, whatever its policy says.

2. The arrangements must be recorded at five or more employees. Regulation 5(2). Worth noting the contrast with fire: the equivalent recording threshold in the Fire Safety Order was removed in October 2023 and now applies to everyone, while regulation 5(2) still has its five-employee qualifier. Two similar duties, two different thresholds.

3. An accident is a reason to suspect the risk assessment is no longer valid. Regulation 3(3) requires any assessment to be reviewed where there is reason to suspect that it is no longer valid or there has been a significant change in the matters to which it relates, and where changes are required they must be made.

This is the cleanest legal argument for investigating. Something happened that the assessment did not prevent. That is, on its face, a reason to suspect the assessment is no longer valid, and the review duty is triggered whether or not the incident was reportable. Our note on individual risk assessments covers the person-specific layer.

4. There is no prescribed method, and that cuts both ways. Nothing specifies who investigates, to what depth, in what timescale or on what form. You set the standard, so a thin investigation breaches no rule, but you are measured against whatever your arrangements promised. Promising a formal root cause investigation for every incident and delivering none is worse than promising a proportionate one.

What must be recorded

5. Reportable incidents must be recorded, with specified particulars. Regulation 12(1)(a) of RIDDOR 2013 requires the responsible person to keep a record of any reportable incident under regulations 4 to 7, containing the particulars specified in paragraphs 5 to 11 of Part 2 of Schedule 1.

The record is a separate duty from the report. Submitting the online form does not discharge regulation 12.

6. Reportable diagnoses too. Regulation 12(1)(b) does the same for diagnoses reportable under regulations 8 to 10, with the particulars in paragraphs 12 to 17.

7. And any injury incapacitating someone for more than three consecutive days. Regulation 12(1)(c) is the provision most often missed. A record must be kept of any injury to a person at work resulting from an accident arising out of or in connection with that work which incapacitates that person for routine work for more than three consecutive days, excluding the day of the accident.

Note the gap. The reporting threshold is over seven days; the recording threshold is over three. So injuries in the four to seven day band must be recorded and need not be reported, and that is exactly the band organisations treat as needing nothing because nothing went to the HSE. Our notes on RIDDOR reportable injuries and the accident book cover both sides.

8. Three years, and a place. Regulation 12(2): an entry must be kept for at least three years from the date it was made, and the record must be kept at the place where the work it relates to is carried on, or at the responsible person's usual place of business.

Two requirements, and the second is the one hybrid organisations fail. A record held only in a cloud folder nobody can locate is not kept at either place in any practical sense.

9. Record what was not reportable as well. Not a legal requirement, so stated as what it is: the incidents that produce the most useful findings are usually the ones with no injury at all. Our note on near miss reporting deals with getting them reported in the first place.

The rights of safety representatives

This is the part most employers do not know exists, and it changes who is in the room.

10. Safety representatives may examine the causes of accidents, uninvited. Regulation 4(1)(a) of the Safety Representatives and Safety Committees Regulations 1977 gives each safety representative the function to investigate potential hazards and dangerous occurrences at the workplace, whether or not they are drawn to his attention by the employees he represents, and to examine the causes of accidents at the workplace.

Read the parenthesis again. The function is not limited to matters raised with them. Where a recognised trade union has appointed safety representatives, examining the causes of accidents is their statutory function, not a courtesy you extend.

11. They may investigate individual complaints. Regulation 4(1)(b): to investigate complaints by any employee they represent relating to that employee's health, safety or welfare at work.

12. And make representations on what they find. Regulation 4(1)(c) and (d): to make representations to the employer on matters arising from those investigations, and on general matters affecting health, safety or welfare at the workplace. Those representations are the output your arrangements have to be able to receive and answer.

The method HSE actually publishes

The HSE's workbook HSG245, Investigating accidents and incidents, sets out four steps. It is free to download and it is the reference point an inspector will recognise.

13. Step one: gathering information. Before analysis, and separate from it. The discipline is to collect what happened without yet explaining it, because the explanation arrives early and then filters the evidence.

14. Steps two and three: analysing the information, then identifying risk control measures. Two steps rather than one, deliberately. Most investigations collapse them, which is how you get a report whose cause is "lack of care" and whose control is "remind staff to be careful". Analysis establishes what allowed the event; identifying controls is a separate exercise against the hierarchy of control. Our note on just culture deals with why the first keeps landing on the individual.

15. Step four: the action plan and its implementation. The step named in two halves, because a plan with no implementation is the commonest failure in this whole field, and it loops straight back to regulation 3(3): the point of the action plan is that the risk assessment changes.

Worth noting who HSG245 is addressed to. Its subtitle is a workbook for employers, unions, safety representatives and safety professionals, which tells you the HSE designed investigation as a joint activity rather than a management process with consultation bolted on.

The fifteen, and what we usually find

RequirementSourceTypical finding
Arrangements for monitoring and reviewMHSWR reg 5(1)No described method
Arrangements recorded at five or more employeesMHSWR reg 5(2)Assumed not to apply
Review the assessment where validity is in doubtMHSWR reg 3(3)Assessment untouched after an incident
No prescribed method, so your own standard appliesNonePolicy promises more than is done
Record reportable incidents with Schedule 1 particularsRIDDOR reg 12(1)(a)Report filed, record not kept
Record reportable diagnosesRIDDOR reg 12(1)(b)Not considered
Record injuries over three consecutive daysRIDDOR reg 12(1)(c)Four to seven day band ignored
Keep entries three years, at the workplace or place of businessRIDDOR reg 12(2)Held nowhere locatable
Capture non-reportable eventsGood practiceNo mechanism
Safety reps may examine causes, uninvitedSRSC reg 4(1)(a)Right unknown to management
Safety reps may investigate complaintsSRSC reg 4(1)(b)Handled as grievance only
Safety reps may make representationsSRSC reg 4(1)(c), (d)No route to receive them
Gather informationHSG245Conclusion reached first
Analyse, then identify controlsHSG245Collapsed into one step
Action plan and implementationHSG245Plan written, not closed out

Rows seven and fifteen are the two we raise most often. Row ten is the one that surprises people, and row three is the one that turns an investigation from paperwork into something that changes a document.

Holding the incident log, the records with their three-year clock, the action plan and the resulting assessment changes in one place is a practical case for health and safety consultants and software working as one system, because the chain from event to amended assessment is where it breaks. Periodic health and safety audits can test it in one move: take the last recorded incident and ask which risk assessment changed as a result.

How investigation duties differ internationally

For groups operating in several countries, this is an area where the British approach is unusually permissive and the gap is easy to miss.

The method travels. Gather, analyse, identify controls, act. That sequence is recognisable anywhere and is worth holding as a group standard.

The obligation does not. Great Britain imposes no express duty to investigate and no prescribed form, leaving it to the general duty to monitor and review. Several other jurisdictions are explicit: Poland requires a formal post-accident procedure and registers, with the Criminal Code cited alongside the Labour Code in the state institute's own employer guidance. Turkey requires investigation of events that caused no injury but damaged, or could have damaged, equipment or the workplace, with notification within three working days. Brazil requires findings to feed a documented action plan inside the risk management programme.

So a group standard built on British discretion will understate the requirement in several countries, most of all where the local rule attaches a deadline or a personal exposure. Our note on key differences in international health and safety legislation sets out the wider pattern.

Where Arinite fits

Most organisations that ask us for help with investigation do not need an investigation procedure. They need the link between the incident and the assessment to exist.

What our health and safety consultants do is write the arrangements regulation 5 requires in terms you can actually meet, set a proportionate threshold for what gets examined and to what depth, make sure the recording duties are discharged separately from reporting, and close the loop so that the action plan ends in an amended risk assessment rather than a closed ticket. Where safety representatives exist, we build their statutory function into the process rather than around it. We support 1,500+ businesses in 50+ countries and protect 100,000+ employees, with 95%+ client retention over 15+ years, across office-based, legal, insurance, IT and software and education clients. For multi-country groups our global health and safety consultants and international health and safety consultants can say which countries impose an express duty and a deadline.

Do one thing this week. Take the last incident anyone recorded and ask two questions: was it recorded as well as reported, and which risk assessment changed because of it. Then book a free gap analysis and we will tell you in one call which of the fifteen you can evidence.

Share this article
A

Written by

Arinite Health & Safety Consultants

Health & Safety Expert at Arinite

Free Resources

Health & Safety Factsheets

Download our comprehensive library of expert guides, checklists, and templates.

Get Professional Help

Need Expert H&S Advice?

Our qualified consultants are ready to support your specific business needs.