Competent Person: The 4 Decisions in Regulation 7

Here is a sentence a health and safety consultancy has no commercial reason to publish.
Regulation 7(8) of the Management of Health and Safety at Work Regulations 1999: where there is a competent person in the employer's employment, that person shall be appointed for the purposes of paragraph (1) in preference to a competent person not in his employment.
Not "may". Not "should consider". The law expresses a preference for your own employee over any external adviser, including us, and it expresses it in mandatory terms. If you have somebody competent inside the business, that is who the regulation says should hold the appointment.
We publish it because the opposite approach produces the single most common failure we find: an organisation that has bought a consultancy retainer, believes the appointment is therefore dealt with, and cannot answer any of the four questions below. The retainer is not the appointment. It may support the appointment, and often should, but regulation 7 forces four decisions and buying a service answers only part of one of them.
Most articles on this subject run through a list of duties. This one takes the four decisions in turn, because that is the order in which they actually have to be made.
Decision one: who holds the appointment
Regulation 7(1) requires every employer to appoint one or more competent persons to assist him in undertaking the measures he needs to take to comply with the relevant statutory provisions. Three features of that wording decide most of what follows.
"To assist him." The appointment is assistance with the employer's duties. It does not become the appointee's duty. Nothing in regulation 7 moves liability, and an external appointment moves it least of all, a point we make in our note on what employer of record arrangements do not cover.
Competence is defined by capability, not by certificate. Regulation 7(5) says a person is competent where they have sufficient training and experience or knowledge and other qualities to enable them properly to assist. Read the conjunctions carefully: training and experience, or knowledge and other qualities. There is no named qualification, no mandatory register and no minimum years. The HSE's own guidance on competence treats it the same way, as a judgement about the person against the work rather than a credential check.
This cuts both ways. An office manager who has run the risk assessments for six years, knows the building and has had relevant training may well be competent for a low-risk office. A consultant with an impressive qualification list who has never seen your premises is not automatically competent for your undertaking.
Then paragraph (8) ranks the candidates. If a competent employee exists, that person is appointed in preference to an external one. So the honest sequence is: establish what your undertaking requires, look inside first, and appoint externally for what is genuinely not there.
Two exemptions are worth knowing because small professional firms often fall inside them. Regulation 7(6) disapplies the duty for a self-employed employer not in partnership who has sufficient training and experience or knowledge and other qualities to undertake the measures themselves. Regulation 7(7) does the same for partnerships where at least one of the partners has those qualities, both to undertake their own measures and to assist their fellow partners.
Decision two: how many, how much time, and what resources
This is the decision almost nobody records, and it is the one with a number attached.
Regulation 7(3) requires the employer to ensure that the number of persons appointed, the time available for them to fulfil their functions, and the means at their disposal are adequate having regard to three things: the size of the undertaking, the risks to which employees are exposed, and the distribution of those risks throughout the undertaking.
That third limb is the useful one. Risk distribution, not just risk level. A single office of two hundred people and eight offices of twenty-five are the same size and present very different appointment questions, and a group with one UK head office plus small teams in six countries is a distribution problem before it is anything else.
Time available is where this most often fails. An appointment given to someone whose job already consumes their week is not an appointment with adequate time, and the regulation makes time an express requirement rather than an implication. If the appointee has four hours a month and the role needs two days, the options are to increase the time, reduce the scope by appointing additional people, or buy in the part that does not fit. Regulation 7(2) covers the second: where more than one person is appointed, the employer must make arrangements for ensuring adequate co-operation between them.
What we would expect to see written down, and rarely do: who is appointed, for what scope, with how much time a month, with what budget, and who else is appointed alongside them. Holding that alongside the assessments, actions and review dates it generates is the practical case for health and safety consultants and software operating as one system rather than a retainer plus a shared drive. Periodic health and safety audits should open with it: who is the appointed competent person, and how much time do they have.
Decision three: what the appointee is entitled to receive
Need Expert H&S Guidance?
Our qualified consultants can help you implement the right health & safety measures for your business.
An appointment without information is decorative, and regulation 7(4) says so in two parts.
For any appointee who is not in the employer's employment, regulation 7(4)(a) requires that they are informed of the factors known by the employer to affect, or suspected by him of affecting, the health and safety of any other person who may be affected by the conduct of the undertaking, and that they have access to the information referred to in regulation 10.
Regulation 10 is a specific list: the risks identified by the assessment, the preventive and protective measures, the emergency procedures, the identity of the persons nominated to implement them, and risks notified by other employers sharing the workplace. So an external adviser is legally entitled to the risk assessments, the arrangements and the names, and an organisation that engages one while withholding half of that has not completed the appointment.
The word "suspected" deserves a moment, because the duty covers factors the employer suspects may affect health and safety, not only those established. The asbestos survey nobody can find, the recurring complaint about a floor, the incident that was never investigated: all of it belongs in the handover, and all of it is what an adviser is usually told last.
Regulation 7(4)(b) adds a second category for every appointee, internal or external: information about any person working in the undertaking who is employed under a fixed-term contract or employed in an employment business. Contractors, temps and agency staff have to be visible to whoever holds the appointment, which in professional firms using contract resource is frequently the population nobody mentions. Our note on management systems covers where that information should sit.
Decision four: what the appointment does not do
The fourth decision is really a decision not to believe something, and it is the reason we wrote this.
An appointment under regulation 7 does not discharge any duty. It provides assistance with duties that remain, in full, with the employer. The structure is the same everywhere we work: in Turkey the law states expressly that obtaining services from external experts does not remove the employer's responsibilities, and in the Netherlands, Germany, Spain and Italy the equivalent provisions all keep the duty with the employer while regulating who may help. The UK simply states it less loudly, by making the appointee's role "to assist".
That has a practical consequence for how an external appointment should be bought. A retainer that delivers documents is cheap and comfortable and leaves the four decisions unanswered. A useful arrangement states who inside the organisation holds the appointment, what the external party is appointed to assist with, what information has been handed over, and how much time exists on both sides. Our note on the honest case for outsourcing covers the commercial side, and our comparison of consultancies how to choose one.
The four decisions, side by side
| Decision | Regulation | What it requires | What we usually find |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who holds it | 7(1), 7(5), 7(8) | Competent person, internal in preference to external | Retainer treated as the appointment |
| Scale and resources | 7(3), 7(2) | Number, time and means adequate to size, risks and their distribution | Nobody has stated the time |
| Information | 7(4), reg 10 | Known and suspected factors, plus the regulation 10 list | Adviser briefed partially |
| What it transfers | 7(1) | Assistance only, duty stays with the employer | Believed to transfer liability |
Row two is the one that fails quietly for years. Row four is the one that fails expensively once.
How the appointment travels internationally
For groups operating in several countries, this is the area where a UK-built model breaks most predictably, because the UK is unusually permissive about who may hold the role.
The method travels: identify what the undertaking requires, appoint someone capable, resource them, inform them, review it. That logic is common across the European Economic Area because it descends from the same framework directive.
The gatekeeping does not. The UK names no qualification and no register, leaving competence to the employer's judgement. Other jurisdictions regulate the appointment itself: the Netherlands requires certified involvement in verifying the risk assessment, Germany ties the role to qualification and works council agreement, Spain requires an organisational model with accredited statutory audit, Italy a non-delegable designation carrying personal criminal exposure, Poland headcount thresholds plus the employer's own training, and Turkey state-certified role holders chosen by hazard class and headcount.
So a group standard that says "appoint a competent person and let local management decide" is compliant in the UK and insufficient in all six. Our notes on the competent person role across jurisdictions and key differences in international legislation set out where the lines fall.
Where Arinite fits
Given how this article opened, our position should be stated plainly: in a good number of the organisations that approach us, the right answer to decision one is an internal appointment, and we will say so.
What our health and safety consultants are useful for is the other three decisions and the parts of the first that are not there: working out what the undertaking requires before anyone is appointed, sizing time and resources against the distribution of risk rather than headcount, building the information handover that regulation 7(4) requires and almost nobody completes, and holding the scope an internal appointee cannot carry alone, which in multi-country groups is usually everything outside the home jurisdiction. Our page on the competent person role sets out that boundary. We support 1,500+ businesses in 50+ countries and protect 100,000+ employees, with 95%+ client retention over 15+ years.
We work extensively with office-based, legal, insurance, IT and software and education clients. In law firms and insurers the appointment usually sits with an operations or facilities lead who has the capability and not the hours, which is a decision-two problem wearing a decision-one disguise. Our notes on the role of competent persons and competent persons in fire safety cover the role itself and the parallel fire appointment.
For multi-country groups, our global health and safety consultants apply the local gatekeeping rules rather than exporting British discretion, and our international health and safety consultants can tell you which countries regulate who may hold the appointment.
Do one thing this week. Ask who your appointed competent person is and how many hours a month they have for it. If the answer is the name of a consultancy, you have found decision one. If it is a name with no hours attached, you have found decision two. Then book a free gap analysis and we will tell you in one call which of the four you can evidence, including where the answer is that you do not need us.
Related Articles
Written by
Arinite Health & Safety Consultants
Health & Safety Expert at Arinite


